Sex with Mentally Ill Inmate???

[soundboy125]

Well desperate, you can argue the law and debate this until you are blue in the face. Your efforts are wasted. Here is the bottom line. The man in the OP was tried and convicted according to the laws and statutes of his state. There is a potential for this to have been tried as rape if the officer in question used his authority to cause duress ie: retaliation if she didn't agree to have sex. That being said we do not know the full circumstances of the case.

As far as you disagreeing with the way the laws are written and/ or enforced, get used to it. If you ever make it into corrections there are going to be literally hundreds of policies and procedures as well as laws that you will disagree with, yet will have to enforce because that will be your job. If you raise this kind of fuss over it and refuse to enforce a law/policy that you disagree with on some technicality, you will be swiftly reprimanded and if you continue you will simply be escorted out the front door. The kind of thinking you are displaying here is a very dangerous mind set inside the walls. You sound like an inmate lover, and you might actually get caught up in the sob stories they tell about how they're not good for what they are down for or how the public defender didn't do his job. You could start feeling bad for all the innocent people locked up, and cut them a break or let an infraction slide. This kind of stuff will eventually get you caught up in a major train wreck. You may want to think long and hard before you put in any more applications. Check yourself before you wreck yourself.

[Dehietyi]

@desperate

Law Encyclopedia: Imprisonment
This entry contains information applicable to United States law only.

Incarceration; the act of restraining the personal liberty of an individual; confinement in a prison.

imprison: Definition, Synonyms and Much More from Answers.com

Political freedom is the right, or the capacity and ability, of self-determination as an expression of the individual will.

Types

The concept of political freedom is closely allied with the concepts of civil liberties and individual rights. Most democratic societies are professedly characterized by various freedoms which are afforded the legal protection of the state. Some of these freedoms may include (in alphabetical order):

* Freedom of assembly
* Freedom of association
* Freedom to bear arms
* Freedom of education
* Freedom of movement (or travel)
* Freedom of the press
* Freedom of religion (or belief)
* Freedom of speech
* Freedom of thought
* Intellectual freedom
* Sexual freedom

freedom: Information and Much More from Answers.com

Medical Encyclopedia:
Rape and Sexual Assault

Definition

The various definitions of rape range from the broad (coercing an individual to engage in any sexual act) to the specific (forcing a woman to submit to sexual intercourse). The United States Code includes the crime of rape under the more comprehensive term "sexual abuse." Two types of sexual assault are defined in the code: sexual abuse and aggravated sexual abuse. Sexual abuse includes acts in which an individual is forced to engage in sexual activity by use of threats or other fear tactics, or instances in which an individual is physically unable to decline. Aggravated sexual abuse occurs when an individual is forced to submit to sexual acts by use of physical force; threats of death, injury, or kidnapping; or substances that render that individual unconscious or impaired.

Description

Many misconceptions exist about rape and sexual assault. It is often assumed that rape victims are all women who have been attacked by a total stranger and forced into having sexual intercourse. In reality, sexual assault can take many forms—it may be violent or nonviolent; the victim may be male or female, child or adult; the offender may be a stranger, relative, friend, authority figure, or spouse.

rape: Definition, Synonyms and Much More from Answers.com

Dictionary:
mental illness

n.

Any of various conditions characterized by impairment of an individual's normal cognitive, emotional, or behavioral functioning, and caused by social, psychological, biochemical, genetic, or other factors, such as infection or head trauma. Also called emotional illness, mental disease; Also called mental disorder.

mental illness: Definition, Synonyms and Much More from Answers.com

I have cited the previous definitions as well as the site and links followed.

I will not argue the fact that I'm sure you were in the debate club; nor will I fault your tenacity. I will however argue your ability to compose clear and definable quid pro quo. You dance around a point by picking out only a small faction in the overall logic. Take this sentence for example: Suzie and Tommy played Mike Tyson's Punch Out. In one instance by taking the words out of context it might read Tommy Punched Out Suzie. Is this the meaning of the sentence? No of course not. Even in your retort toward me you did not fault my logic rather took a small portion of what I said out of context in order to find fault. Misconstruing an individuals words to support your ends is not a valid debate. In this instance it was you who is at fault for initiating disrespect in this thread. Having said that I have cited the previous definitions to backup not only my own claims but the claims of those who have wasted their time trying to carry logical thought in this nonsensical thread. She was incarcerated. She has multiple mental disorders. A CO had sex with her. He was found guilty of committing a crime in this capacity. Incarceration is the loss of personal freedom. Mental Illness is an impairment of an individuals mental function. Rape and Sexual Assault have been PC'd to the blanket term Sexual Abuse. In the same respect Shell Shock has become Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. So your argument on the definition of rape is pointless in the eyes of the United States Judicial Code.

In this respect I stand on my previous remarks and unlike you I have better things to do with my time than argue pointless semantics. You are not Bill Clinton, We are not the governing body of the impeachment hearings and I will not continue to listen to your definitions of the word IS. When you have a real point to make or say something of interest that is not related to your compulsion of I will be more than willing to listen and retort. I was wrong about one thing though; you should not be banned. Being ignorant is not grounds for banning someone but rather ignoring them.

[jblevins]

Hey desperate if your arguing for lulz theres other places like 4chan but I really think if your looking to be a CO, debating policy and enforcing it are two different things.
Are you sure this is what you want to do, just seems like you would have more fun in a courtroom.